Is football too violent for Christians?

As Americans feel the chill of a fall breeze, thoughts turn to Thanksgiving, Christmas and football. There is no doubt football has become America’s sporting obsession. Football games are huge events where fans dress up, chant, cheer and tailgate. Even though a football team only has a handful of home games each season, the atmosphere and pageantry of football attracts countless people who are fans of the spectacle more than the nuances of the zone read, Tampa 2 or the wing-bone offense. No other game combines brute force and elegant choreography the way football does.

But there are those who question the acceptability of a physically combative sport like football. They consider the game barbaric or a blood sport. Author Malcolm Gladwell, who is calling for the abolition of college football, refers to football as the human version of dog fighting. President Obama was recently quoted as saying, “I’m a big football fan, but I have to tell you, if I had a son, I’d have to think long and hard before I let him play football.” Our friend and colleague, Owen Strachan, recently wrote an article, “Our Shaken Faith in Football,” addressing the question, “Should Christian fans step away from such a physically devastating, violent sport?”

The question of whether football is too violent to be deemed ethically acceptable is not a new one. In 1905, the game was far more violent and brutal than today – 18 men died on the college football field, which led then Harvard president Charles Eliot to describe the game as having “barbarous ethics” worse than “cockfighting” and to call for the abolition of football on college campuses. In response, President Theodore Roosevelt described such an attitude as foolish and stated his concern about producing “mollycoddles instead of vigorous men.” Roosevelt said, “I believe in rough games and in rough, manly sports” and asserted he had no intention of allowing Eliot to “emasculate football.” He committed himself to doing everything he could to save football. His efforts resulted in a few changes that rescued the manly game he loved.

Roosevelt had been a football fan since he was an 18-year-old Harvard freshman and witnessed his first game in 1876 against rival Yale. He was a war hero in the 1880s and 1890s and led the Rough Riders to military victory in Cuba. While recruiting men for the Rough Riders, he looked for those who had been cowboys, ranchers and football players. In a speech urging men to live a strenuous life he said, “In short, in life, as in a football game, the principle to follow is: hit the line hard; don’t foul and don’t shirk, but hit the line hard!” In “The Big Scrum: How Teddy Roosevelt Saved Football,” John J. Miller writes, “In Roosevelt’s estimation, the foes of football were wrongheaded idealists who simply refused to accept the risks that are attached to virtually any human endeavor. They threatened to feminize an entire generation.”

Roosevelt’s willingness to listen to concerns, but his ultimate defense of a brand of football far more brutish and violent than today, is instructive for the contemporary conversation about the ethics of the combat sport. We should always be willing to reform the game in ways that reduce risk but do not destroy the very character of the physical and manly sport. The National Football League recently reached a $765 million settlement with 4,500 former players seeking damages from the NFL for concealing the long-term damages of concussion related injuries. Research shows that repeated hits to the head are linked to chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), a degenerative brain disease that can result in mood disorders and dementia. The NFL certainly does have an ethical responsibility to inform players embarking on a professional football career of the existing data and potential dangers related to a career in the game.

Nevertheless, it is wrongheaded to use data from NFL football players who have made the game their career at the highest level and attribute it to everyone who plays football. An estimated 3.9 million people participate in playing football in America each year and of that number only 68,000 participate on the college level and 1,696 are on NFL rosters. More than 95 percent of the people who participate in tackle football are under 18 years of age. It is nonsensical to use data related to career NFL football players and use the findings to cast a dark shadow on football in general. There is a qualitative difference between playing youth football and the National Football League. However, despite the logical difference, many American parents are keeping their children out of youth football; according to an annual survey by the national Federation of State high school associations, more than 25,000 fewer kids played football in the US in 2012 than only four years before. This is tragic.

Recent studies published in the medical journal, “Mayo Clinic Proceedings,” concluded, “Long-term excessive endurance exercise may induce pathological structural remodeling of the heart and large arteries…[and] excessive exercise significantly increases mortality.” In other words, new research suggests that long-term running at extreme levels may damage one’s health and has a relationship to heart disease and premature death. If this research were taken to argue that youth physical fitness programs which emphasized running were dangerous and should be avoided because of potential heart problems, that would be an illogical and wrongheaded overreaching application of the data. It is akin to arguing that health concerns about repeated head trauma of college and professional football players means that youth football is dangerous and should be avoided.

A March 2012 study by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health found that NFL players are living longer than men in the general population. They had a much lower rate of cancer-related deaths, and the risk of dying from heart disease or suicide was also lower than that of the general population. The primary area of concern was that NFL players had a greater risk of death involving neurodegenerative causes than that of the general population (still less than one percent of the players studied). As Daniel Flynn has notes in his book, “War on Football,” “On the whole, people who play football are going to walk away from the game healthier than the people who sit in the stands and watch it.”

As we normally reckon safety, football is a safe activity and it is getting safer. In the 1960s there was an average of about 25 football related deaths a season. The average now is around four. Every death is tragic and the death of a young person bears a unique pain, but the risk of experiencing a football related fatality is remarkably low. To provide some perspective, in 2011, there were twice as many cyclists treated for head injuries than football players and 91 cycling fatalities under 20 years of age as compared to four on the football field.

In the September 5, 2011, edition of the Houston Chronicle, Dr. Gary Brock, who specializes in pediatric surgery asserts, “We see more catastrophic injuries among cheerleaders than among any group of athletes…The risk per hour of activity is seven times greater than with other participatory sports…I tell parents that it’s safer to send their children to Pop Warner (football), than to the playground.”

As Christians, we believe that it is our responsibility to take every thought captive to obey Christ (2 Cor 10:5). This means that followers of Jesus are right to question their participation in any activity, including football. Football is a rough, physically demanding sport that involves the strategic and deliberate use of force to gain territory and reach the goal line. Every football game consists of a series of controlled violent physical encounters between opposing teams resembling a small-scale pre-modern war. Thus, it is not surprising that football contains a great deal of terminology borrowed from the battlefield and protective equipment resembling military armor. Victory on the battlefield and the football field both require a great deal of teamwork, trust, self-sacrifice, suffering, as well as, physical and mental courage.

While the Bible does not mention modern sports like football, it has much to say about warfare and Kingdom, and it draws a relationship between sport and war. Sporting contests are artificially constructed mini-battles, whether they are wrestling or boxing matches (both specifically mentioned in the Bible), or baseball and football. And the lessons learned agonizing and striving in one can readily prove instructive for the other (Heb 12:1-4, 1 Cor 9:24-27, Eph 6:12, Phil 3:13-14). In fact, the primary images in the Bible describing the struggle of living as God’s people are: soldier, athlete and farmer (2 Tim 2:4-7). Each calling is difficult and physically demanding, requiring a man to train and sacrifice his body. The use of sports imagery in the Scripture is instructive and overwhelmingly positive in drawing a link between sports, war and ministry in the Kingdom of Christ. It is also not surprising that just as warfare tactics have changed from the ancient world to the modern world, so also have sports shifted from a focus on individual sports to a focus on team sports.

The obvious link between sports and warfare explains why Gen. Douglas MacArthur carved, “Upon the fields of friendly strife are sown the seeds that, upon other fields, on other days, Will bear the fruits of victory,” on the stone passageway leading to the West Point gym. The rugged, physically demanding, purposeful aggression of football is an asset, not a liability. A football game consists of a series of battles that have a beginning and an end. There are tactics in the battle that are dependent on knowing a team’s strength and the other team’s weaknesses. Football rewards specialized individual skill as long as it is subordinated to the greater goal of team victory. The sport provides a consistent and valuable metaphor for contemporary churches that need to remember that the Great Commission is not a public relations campaign, but rather a war cry that demands self-sacrifice.

There are inevitable risks tied to every human endeavor and we are right to count the cost, but we must also be concerned about the moral, therapeutic deism that equates Christianity with being a nice guy and views God as a benevolent being who helps us be nice guys. Laziness and intentional underachievement, along with a safety-centric worldview are enemies to the advancement of the gospel. Likewise, there is a price to pay on the football field for laziness and lack of focus.

Football represents one of the only major American institutions still standing that is exclusively for males and speaks unashamedly about manliness and toughness. Boys are drawn to demanding physical competition against other boys, assertive male leadership, and a cause that demands sacrifice and calculated risk. These are good things that ought to be cultivated on a pathway from boyhood to Christian manhood.

Courage and calculated risk-taking are causalities of our contemporary safety-centric worldview. Sadly, evangelicals seem to be leading the movement to train bravery and adventure out of our children in favor of a cult of safety. Boys, who are virtually bubble wrapped by their parents to ride bikes in the front yard and do not participate in things like football because they might get hurt, will have a difficult time finding Paul remotely intelligible when he asserts, “For I am ready not only to be imprisoned but even to die in Jerusalem for the name of the Lord Jesus” (Acts 20:13).

Anthony Esolen has noted that football uniquely stirs the passions and intellectual interest of boys and men because it speaks the sacrificial language of men in a way the contemporary church often misses. He writes, “If it is said that women are more spiritual than men because more of them are to be found in churchly places, I’m not buying. I’ll take the sacramentality of football over the spirituality of uplifting chatter any day. A true man, and there are many still, struggling to be both true and man, would sooner have his right arm wither than the change loyalty to the Pittsburgh Steelers. Yet he leaves the church. Why? Sin, of course; but in fact the Pittsburgh Steelers present themselves as more worthy of loyalty than does a church that demands nothing” (Touchstone, “What Sports Illustrates”).

We are certainly not defending everything that surrounds our modern American infatuation with football. We are sickened by the predatory cheating culture that surrounds major college athletics. We are also deeply troubled by professing Christians for whom the metaphor of sport becomes more important to them then the reality to which it points. We applaud attempts to reform football that do not destroy the essence of the manly game and support the penalization of those who corrupt the game by intentionally attempting to injure an opponent. We are saddened every time a player gets injured on the football field, but no more so than when one is injured in a cycling or skateboarding accident.

Nevertheless, we believe that Roosevelt was wise when he recruited men who had played football for his Rough Riders military unit. We also believe that a few more ministers of the gospel who have served in the military, played football or farmed would strengthen the church. We need to be reminded that we do not just surrender our brains to Christ, we surrender our very selves, including our bodies. If football did not exist in modern America, some Christian man would need to invent it. Our Christian worldview and ethics demand the proving ground of football or at least something like it.

The church is in desperate need of some Christian Rough Riders who are willing to serve the church self-sacrificially and enter spiritual battle, no matter the cost. The modern church has too many mollycoddles instead of vigorous men, and our mission demands the latter.

David E. Prince is the pastor of preaching and vision at Ashland Avenue Baptist Church. He is also an assistant professor of Christian Preaching at the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary.

Jimmy Scroggins is the senior pastor of First Baptist Church of West Palm Beach.

Further Learning

Learn more about: Culture,

21 Comments

1 On Sep 25, 2013, at 2:01pm, Ryan wrote:

I think this fantastic article needs to be read by parents of sons.

I recently told my children this story: as a running back on my 8th grade football team, I was pass protecting our QB, and the opposing team’s left defensive end and I were colliding during a series of consecutive plays. He was one of those early-bloomers and, well, I was not. He was literally throwing me aside every play. But, despite my strength and size deficit, I was getting back up every time and going to meet him without backing down. I learned from that experience (and countless others in sports) the life-lesson to be tenacious and tough, despite weakness.

While a gospel minister doesn’t often recall such experiences to mind directly, the providential battles sports provided growing up are nonetheless sown into the fabric of his soul. And when ministry resembles more of a hellish war than a comfy couch, such lessons are invaluable.

Thank you for your time, effort, research, and skill in this article.

2 On Sep 25, 2013, at 3:40pm, Steve Griffin wrote:

There will always be people who cringe at the toughest sport they see and insist it be stopped. They’ve all but abolished boxing, and so football is now the next worse thing they see. One hundred years from now they’ll protest the javelin toss because someone’s eye could be put out.

3 On Sep 25, 2013, at 3:41pm, Ian wrote:

I never got into football as a child, but being from Michigan, I played hockey. Many people that have never seen it on person (not on tv) don’t know how fast the players are actually moving- quicker than football during much of the time and is pretty violent. You get taught how to take and throw hits and you try to protect yourself when you can. I think the battles we learn on the sportsfield (or ice) can be very beneficial to our character and faith.

Much like what Ryan said above about always getting back up when knocked down, that’s truly a Christian mentality. There are times we are tempted and times that we might give in. Do we stay in our guilt and not get back up? No, we ask for forgiveness, repent and get back up to fight another day, seeking the Lord’s help. If you take those battles out of our lives, in this case young children’s lives, what’s going to happen the first time they get knocked down (literally or not) never having any experience with it?

4 On Sep 25, 2013, at 8:23pm, Jamie wrote:

Wow!  The homophobic undercurrent in this piece is appalling.

5 On Sep 25, 2013, at 9:24pm, HS Shin wrote:

“We are saddened every time a player gets injured on the football field, but no more so than when one is injured in a cycling or skateboarding accident.”

The authors of this article should speak for themselves. A cycling injury is NOT the same as a quarterback suffering a concussion because a linebacker wanted to prove a point.

6 On Sep 25, 2013, at 10:07pm, cbris schrader wrote:

Nothing like a good old fashioned borderline brainwashing about what it means to be a man… football,  seriously?  So the young men who God created smallish in stature should become sacrificial lambs to prove their ready to mount up with Teddy? I’m just as comfortable going to battle with any man who knows the battle belongs to the Lord… football player,  distance runner,  hockey player,  artist,  wheelchair bound…

7 On Sep 25, 2013, at 11:18pm, Luke wrote:

My childhood was spent in the wilderness of Alaska. Days were filled with chopping wood, trapping, working and playing at the side of my father. My brother and i shot and caught dinner for our family being only 4 and 5 years old. My dad taught us boys how to be men, in the way He worshipped Christ, loved my mom and broke his body in labor to provide for us…all done in joy. We had moved to WA by the time i reached high school and I played football on two different teams. Now I believe there are a few good lessons we can learn by participating in football, but I do not agree that it produces manly men. Fathers produce men from boys. Like a farmer who raises his crop up strong and rooted deep into good soil, so is the father who cultivates his sons in Worship of Christ, the sacrificial serving love towards his wife (their mother), and teaching them to “hit the line hard” at whatever they put their hands to.

8 On Sep 25, 2013, at 11:24pm, Luke wrote:

(Part 2)
Football cannot replace Fatherhood…..and believe me, it does! Coaches are the fathers of this day in age, they spend more time with our sons, training and teaching them than we do. And truthfully, I could care less if my son ever plays a contact sport, that is not what will shape him into the image of Christ (Who is the manliest man of all time!) It is up to me, his dad, to love my FATHER in heaven with all of my heart, soul and MIGHT, to love my wife like Christ loves His bride, the church. And like Paul, work harder than all the others and show that it is not I, but Christ that works in me.
Our sissy sons do not need more contact sports, they need more contact with DAD and dad.
Grace and peace.

9 On Sep 26, 2013, at 9:25am, Eric wrote:

Wow.  Great article, Biblically sound points, and much needed perspective for our culture today.  Let’s “run that we may win” the ultimate prize!

10 On Sep 26, 2013, at 11:20am, Shannon wrote:

Let’s not miss the point. This article is about raising our sons to have courage and take risks. Team sports can teach these important leadership qualities like few other things in life. And while I agree that we have gone overboard with youth sports, moderate and balanced involvement can be a very healthy thing.

11 On Sep 26, 2013, at 12:34pm, Chris wrote:

As I enter my 41st year of running, first coaching job 33 years ago,  and two children as DI athletes… it is too simplistic to say “sports builds character.”  Without gospel- centered coaching &  parenting, football,  in and of itself, has no power to produce men after God’s own heart.  Football is merely one tool that can be used towards that goal… if wielded properly.

12 On Sep 26, 2013, at 1:51pm, Rob wrote:

So did the Apostle Paul, who took a beating and kept on going learn tenacity and perseverance from football, the ancient arena or from a full understanding and heart belief in the importance of the gospel and the real victory to be won.  To me, your argument is weak and very subjectively attempting to justify a modern sport in the name of God.  And truly, Men do not become strong men after God’s heart because they play sports, but because the Great I AM calls them and saves them and changes their heart from a heart of stone to a heart that lives and breathes Christ.

13 On Sep 27, 2013, at 10:22am, Scott Landers wrote:

Football is too violent for the “men” of the church today. They are just feminized eunuchs. I no longer attend church because I just couldn’t take anymore of it. When feminists have been after every masculine institution for over 30 years and Albert Mohler has just now figured it out you know leadership in the church is non-existent.

14 On Sep 27, 2013, at 3:31pm, Bob wrote:

Great article. Teddy Roosevelt is the man! Football affords an opportunity to face great challenges and how to deal with loss and victory. Not everyone can play it, but that doesn’t make you less of a man. I played pop werner and backyard tackle football and it was awesome even though I was undersized. I’ve had the snot knocked out me but I discovered the courage to go back into the fray. Does football build character or reveal it? The answer is yes.

15 On Sep 27, 2013, at 4:18pm, Jason wrote:

I guess it’s easy to miss the point of the article. Maybe not everyone is meant to play football. In that ADR I probably shouldn’t have. I was the smallest on my team. Eventually worked my way to quarterback. Eventually got replaced after an interception cost us a game. Got sick like everyone else from two a day practices and running in the late summer heat. Got knocked out a few times. But it absolutely changed my life. I learned to face my fears. Trust people I knew were in it with me. Move past parent/coach politics. I saw myself achieve things I never thought possible. I pushed my body to extreme limits. No it doesn’t have to be football. But it can be. And it doesn’t make the article any less true for there to exist such a passion to see those experiences play out on a football field. There is no intention of making this a savior to anyone. I’m sure there are plenty who would spiritualize an objection. But in it’s due place I say this. Thank God for football!

16 On Sep 28, 2013, at 11:27am, Wayne wrote:

Well said Jimmy, Jimmy makes several points that are eye opening and should be considered about our society.  I think he is addressing the illogical liberal mindset that is prevalent in our country. The same mind set that says the government knows best, the same thinking that says abortion is choice not murder.  A 26-year-old adult should still be on their parents health care coverage? Really!  Life is risky at best the liberal mindset that risk and injury can be eliminated is unrealistic.  We have liberty because of Christianity not Christianity because of liberty in our country so, if we want to protect something, let’s protect liberty even if the results of our actions and choices don’t turn out the way others think it should.

17 On Oct 1, 2013, at 1:41pm, Josh wrote:

Yes, football can teach a kind of manliness, but isn’t it a false equivalence to say that football teaches courage and therefore it is good? There are lots of things that teach courage but that you wouldn’t and shouldn’t endorse. And you make nods to the problems associated with the game as currently played (cheating, misuse of the metaphor of sports, injuries), but when do those problems outweigh the good of Christians’ continued participation? When men start skipping church or family times to watch a game (check)? When dads are more involved as coaches than they are as dads (check)? When our ways of thinking and being in the world are tuned and refined by the ads, machismo, and competitive nature of the game (harder to measure, but you bet it’s happening)? Look, I like football, but this article made me rethink - maybe I should stop watching and playing football and find other ways to be trained in courage.

18 On Oct 15, 2013, at 10:06pm, Charles Tysoe wrote:

“Our Christian worldview and ethics demand the proving ground of football or at least something like it.”

For instance?

Say, Christian Spartans? “If you’re not holding your shield when you return from battle, make sure it’s because it’s being used to carry your cold, dead body. Any other outcome will disgrace your family, your church and your school”

The appalling thing about what you men have written is that it contains a certain element of truth.  Like that beverage that contains “5% real fruit juice”

What sort of shepherds are you?

19 On Oct 25, 2013, at 1:57pm, PJ Harrison wrote:

Almost 20 years ago I met Dr. Scroggins’ father at an FCA retreat where I was a huddle leader.  I was a scout teamer at the University of Fla. struggling with a call to ministry.  I doubt he remembers it, but observing him and his players had a great impact on me.

Fathers are essential. But as a kid pastor I believe our kids need adults around them who say the same things we say.  Sadly my experience as a HS teacher and coach tells me very, very few boys have a positive male CHRISTIAN role model. Football is a powerful tool for called coaches.  The world needs more coaches like Jim Scroggins.

20 On Oct 25, 2013, at 7:28pm, Curtis W. Luna wrote:

Football could and should be made safer, better helmets (there already out there)  better pads, and when a player continues to play dirty “Suh” he should be disbard from the game and fined heavily.

21 On Nov 13, 2013, at 12:34pm, Jordan Snell wrote:

Accidental head trauma is different from chronic head trauma by design, i.e., players line up across from each other and repeatedly bash into one other. Please don’t try to use God to defend a sport.
sport (spôrt/):
1. noun: an activity involving physical exertion and skill in which an individual or team competes against another or others for entertainment.

The comment thread for this article is now closed. Please use our contact form.

You May Also Like

Gosnell found guilty of 3 murders outside womb

By Tom Strode - May 14, 2013

A Philadelphia jury has found Kermit Gosnell guilty of the first-degree murder of three babies killed outside the womb at his abortion clinic.

The jury returned the verdicts Monday afternoon (May 13) after deliberating for nearly two weeks.…

Read More

ERLC hires five new staff members during trustee meeting

Sep 11, 2013

WASHINGTON—During its annual gathering of trustees, the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention named three executives and two additional staff members Sept. 11: Phillip Bethancourt, Daniel Patterson, Daniel Darling, Joe Carter and Trillia Newbell.…

Read More