LIFE DIGEST: ‘Selective reduction’ results in 2 dead boys
- Nov 29, 2011 -
An Australian couple’s choice for “selective reduction” of their unborn twins resulted in the death of both boys.
In a Nov. 22 procedure at Royal Women’s Hospital in Melbourne, an ultrasound clinician attempted to abort a twin diagnosed with a heart defect but instead accidentally administered a lethal injection to the healthy son. The boy with the heart defect then was aborted, according to the Herald Sun, a Melbourne newspaper.
Also in this edition: Minnesota abortion clinic to close, fifth in month, More abortions, more funding in England than thought, and Abortion doula ‘never been more in’ despite gruesomeness.
The unnamed parents were told one of the twins had a heart defect that would require numerous operations if he were to survive. Following doctors’ advice, they decided to abort this son in a procedure referred to as “selective reduction.” The unidentified clinician checked on the healthy baby before proceeding with the injection of what was supposed to be the ill twin. The twins, who were in separate sacs, were at 32 weeks’ gestation, the Herald Sun reported.
The mother “went to the hospital with two babies and now she has none. . . . She’s traumatized,” an unidentified friend told the Herald Sun.
A hospital spokeswoman said, “This is a terrible tragedy and the hospital is deeply sorry for the loss suffered by the patient and her family.” The clinician was reportedly inconsolable, the newspaper reported.
The tragic events offer “a stark warning to recognize and resist the eugenic mindset. Our priorities should be to develop treatments and supportive measures for those with genetic disease; not to search them out and destroy them before birth,” said pro-life, bioethics commentator Peter Saunders.
“It is interesting that the killing of an ‘unwanted’ child with special needs in the womb is regarded as ‘normal’ whilst the killing of a ‘wanted’ normal child is seen as a tragedy and worthy of international news coverage,” wrote Saunders, chief executive officer of the England-based Christian Medical Fellowship.
“And yet if the ‘abnormal’ baby had actually been born, doctors would presumably have done everything possible to provide what treatment or care they could. After all the twins were at 32 weeks gestation, 8 weeks past the accepted threshold of viability. Instead however they ensured that it was not born alive by ‘terminating it.’
“Of course if the second ‘normal’ child had also been ‘unwanted’ then the story would not have warranted a mention. Abortion of ‘unwanted’ ‘normal’ babies takes place over 40 million times every year around the world.”
Minnesota abortion clinic to close, fifth in month
A St. Paul, Minn., abortion clinic became Nov. 25 the fifth such center in the United States to signal in November it would be closing.
Regions Hospital announced it would shut down its GYN Special Services Clinic Dec. 9. The clinic performed 545 abortions in 2010, a decline from more than 900 a decade before, according to the Minneapolis Star Tribune.
Earlier in November, the closing of two abortion clinics in Michigan, one in Los Angeles and one in Santa Fe, N.M., was announced.
Pro-life leaders in Minnesota said it was the first abortion clinic in the state to close in two decades, LifeSiteNews.com reported.
Regions Hospital said its decision was based on the decrease in abortions and the availability of the procedure at other clinics in the area, according to the Star Tribune. Five other clinics in the state performed more than 1,000 abortions last year, led by Planned Parenthood of Minnesota, North Dakota and South Dakota. The Planned Parenthood affiliate reported more than 4,000 abortions in 2010, according to the newspaper.
Pro-life leaders said prayer vigils and demonstrations outside the St. Paul clinic helped lead to its shutdown. The 40 Days for Life campaign has conducted seven vigils at the clinic in recent years.
“The closure of this abortion clinic is a testament to the steadfastness and faithfulness of pro-lifers who worked to end the killing without giving up. God honored their work,” Operation Rescue President Troy Newman said in a written statement. “The number of abortion clinics continues a sharp decline, and that translates into lives saved. November has been a great month for the cause of life.”
More abortions, more funding in England than thought
There are far more abortions in England at a much greater cost to British taxpayers than was previously estimated, a new report shows.
Updated statistics from the Department of Health show there were about 173,000 abortions in England last year, according to The Telegraph. That is 21 percent higher than the total of 136,000 previously reported.
The new figures also indicated the government spent about $184 million in the equivalent of American money for abortions during 2009-10, about 24 percent more than the $140 million estimated previously.
In addition, far more of the total funding for abortions was given to private providers than was reported earlier. It had been estimated less than $13 million went to private organizations such as Marie Stopes International and the British Pregnancy Advisory Service. The new statistics show $117 million was granted to such clinics. The remainder went to National Health Service hospitals, according to The Telegraph.
The updated and more reliable figures came by using statistics reported directly to the Chief Medical Officer instead of those calculated by the Department of Health, the health minister in the House of Lords reported.
The news demonstrated why an amendment to require women considering abortion to receive counseling from someone other than an abortion provider is needed, said advocates for the legislation. Parliament rejected such an amendment in September
“If anything proves that the link between the abortion provider and the woman facing a crisis pregnancy should be broken, this is it – too much money changes hands for anyone to argue that the private abortion provider can remain objective during the decision-making process,” said Nadine Dorries, a Conservative Party member who introduced the measure, The Telegraph reported.
Abortion doula ‘never been more in’ despite gruesomeness
At least one abortion doula has no argument with the grisly photos of aborted babies displayed by some pro-lifers, and their reality has done nothing to quell her support of abortion.
“Those pictures pro-life activists flash are real,” Mary Mahoney told The New York Observer in a Nov. 14 feature on abortion doulas. “That is what a fetus looks like when its head is crushed. When you see the procedure, you must decide, as a pro-choice person, whether you are in or out.
“I have never been more in,” she said.
Doulas typically serve pregnant women by providing support before and during childbirth. Recent years have seen some doulas also assisting women who choose abortion with such aids as counseling and back rubs, according to The Observer.
The Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission works to protect the sanctity of human life. If you would like to learn more about this issue, additional resources are available here. Our free, downloadable Impact resource is also available online. If your church is interested in purchasing materials on the sanctity of human life, please visit our online bookstore and erlc.com.
Further Learning
Learn more about: Life, Abortion, Citizenship, National, Science, Bioethics,