Pledge Protection Act gains OK in House

By Tom Strode - Sep 30, 2004 - comment

The House of Representatives approved a bill Sept. 23 to bar federal courts from considering challenges to the Pledge of Allegiance.

The House voted 247-173 for the Pledge Protection Act, H.R. 2028. The legislation, known as a “court-stripping” measure, would remove legal challenges to the pledge’s content from the jurisdiction of all federal courts, including the Supreme Court. Instead, state courts would determine the constitutionality of the pledge within their jurisdictions.

It is unlikely the Senate will pass the bill this session. The target date for adjournment is Oct. 8.

The House vote came three months after the Supreme Court protected the phrase “under God” in the pledge without ruling on its constitutionality under the First Amendment’s ban on government establishment of religion.

The justices unanimously agreed to overrule the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals’ decision that a California school district’s policy requiring recitation of the pledge is unconstitutional. A majority, however, based the court’s opinion on a technicality rather than a constitutional matter. The court decided atheist Michael Newdow did not have legal standing to represent his daughter in the challenge to the pledge. Newdow shares custody of the elementary-age girl with her mother, who has the final say when the parents differ.

As a result of the decision, American schools maintained the right to have the recitation of the pledge as part of their classroom practice, but the possibility exists the high court may rule in a later case that “under God” violates the establishment clause.

Further Learning

Learn more about: Citizenship, Christian Citizenship, Church and State, Legislation, Religious Liberty

Post a Comment




Notify me of follow-up comments?

Before You Submit Your Comment (below), Read This:

Thank you for your interest in the ministry of the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission (SBC).

Comments are moderated to preserve the family-oriented nature of this website and in an attempt to avoid comment spam. We welcome opposing viewpoints, and we will not turn comments away as long as your views are presented with respect to everyone.

Your comments will not appear immediately and are subject to editing or deletion. We will make every attempt to check new comments in a timely manner, though there will likely be delays on the weekends and around holidays.

Please follow the these guidelines to insure your comments will be posted:

  1. Use a real name, at least a real first name. We find folks are less-rude online when not hiding behind a screen-name.
  2. Name-calling and vulgar-language will not be tolerated. Zero-tolerance is our policy. We will not spend time editing profanity. If it contains foul language, your post will be deleted. Oh, and we decide what is and what is not vulgar.
  3. Comments must be on topic. General comments (compliments, complaints, and otherwise) are best delivered here or expressed on your own personal Web site.
  4. And please, do not type in ALL CAPS. It looks like you're screaming at people.

Additionally, within Baptist polity, please recognize that many issues and decisions are addressed at a local church level. SBC denominational (national) offices have no control and desire no control over the activities of a local church. This entity is not responsible for overseeing and insuring the ethical behavior of Southern Baptist pastors or church members. If your concern involves a legal civil or criminal matter, we suggest you contact the proper local officials.

Issues involving pastoral staff or other church members, local Baptist associations or state Baptist conventions are local issues. Therefore the Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission cannot and should not address such issues. While we regret we are unable to assist you, we encourage you to seek a biblical resolution of the issue at the local church level. If your question or submission pertains to a matter covered in this text, it is likely we will not acknowledge your submission.

Other than that, we welcome you and hope to see thoughtful discussions at ERLC.com