Article  Life  Sanctity of Life

ERLC defends pro-life speech in latest SCOTUS brief

Imagine a federal appeals court ruling that the government has the right to prohibit a nonprofit pregnancy resource center for advertising its pregnancy testing, ultrasounds, and counseling to women considering abortion.

This is the reality for First Resort, Inc., a pregnancy resource center targeted by the City of San Francisco for buying Google Ads to advertise its services to any search results for “abortion in San Francisco.” Last June, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that by advertising through Google Ads, First Resort violated a city ordinance making it unlawful for a “limited services pregnancy center” to make statements about its services that were “untrue or misleading, whether by statement or omission.”

What’s the problem? First, nothing in First Resort’s ad was untrue or misleading.  The center was simply advertising its services, which primarily help women considering abortion. Secondly, by prohibiting the nonprofit from advertising its services, the city is blatantly violating the First Amendment.  

Now, First Resort has appealed the Ninth Circuit’s decision to the Supreme Court, and the ERLC is weighing in. Earlier this month, we filed our second pro-life amicus brief this year at the Supreme Court of the United States, advocating that the Supreme Court protect the First Amendment and the U.S. Constitution by striking down this patently unconstitutional law.

The ERLC joined the Christian Legal Society, the Institutional Religious Freedom Alliance, the Lutheran Church—Missouri Synod, and Democrats for Life in a friend-of-the-court brief defending the First Amendment free speech and free exercise rights of pregnancy resource centers and other religious nonprofits serving those in need.

San Francisco claims that it is only regulating “false” or “misleading” speech, but the facts of this case prove that an overly broad commercial speech regulation allows hostile governments to target organizations with religious or ideological perspectives. In this case, it’s San Francisco targeting pro-life pregnancy resource centers. In other states, it could be governments targeting immigrant or refugee-services centers, food pantries, or homeless shelters.

As our brief states,

Today it is pro-life pregnancy counseling centers that hostile government officials aim to restrict, in San Francisco and elsewhere. Tomorrow it may be immigrant or refugee-services centers in states or localities hostile to immigration, or food pantries or homeless shelters in comfortable suburban neighborhoods. In either case, government may not use the “commercial speech” label to distort or suppress speech by organizations that provide free services from motives that are primarily ideological and only tangentially commercial.

It’s been a busy month for the ERLC at the Supreme Court. Earlier this week, another major pro-life Supreme Court case (NIFLA v. Becerra) had oral arguments. We filed a brief in January in that case. Go here to read more and sign up for updates about our pro-life advocacy at the Supreme Court, on Capitol Hill, and around the country.



Related Content

federal regulations

Explainer: 5 additional federal regulations the ERLC is pushing back against

Part three

Part 1Part 2 Over the past month, the Biden administration has finalized numerous problematic...

Read More

How the ERLC has served Southern Baptists in 2023

The Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission exists to assist Southern Baptist churches by helping...

Read More

What does pro-life ministry look like in California?

A pregnancy resource center comes alongside vulnerable mothers

With shifting policies and restrictions related to life and abortion across the country, pro-life...

Read More

Four recent events related to abortion

In June, the pro-life movement celebrated the one-year anniversary of Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s...

Read More
post-Roe world

March For Life in a post-Roe world

An interview with Jeanne Mancini

With last year’s Dobbs v. Jackson Women’s Health Organization decision overturning the precedent of...

Read More
culture of life

10 ways to foster a culture of life within your family

What does it look like practically to create a culture of life within a...

Read More