Article  Human Dignity  Life  Marriage and Family  Religious Liberty  Abortion  Religious Liberty

Reversal of HHS Contraceptive Mandate is Good News for Religious Liberty

On Friday, October 6, 2017, the Trump Administration released a new rule that provides robust religious liberty exemptions to the United States Department of Health and Human Services’ (HHS) contraceptive mandate.

The contraceptive mandate was established in 2010 by the Obama Administration. It requires employers to provide coverage for contraceptives, including contraceptives with abortifacient properties. This mandate had only a narrow exception for houses of worship, but not for religious nonprofits or institutions. This meant that those with deeply held religious objections to abortion were forced by the government to violate those beliefs and pay for products that cause abortions.

In response, the Little Sisters of the Poor, a ministry of Roman Catholic women that serve the elderly poor, along with Guidestone Financial Resources and many other Baptist institutions filed suit against HHS to challenge the contraceptive mandate. The ERLC has been involved in this challenge from the beginning. These organizations were not asking that the contraceptive mandate itself be overturned but rather that an exemption be created for those organizations with deeply held religious objections to the mandate. This challenge made it to the Supreme Court in 2016 as the case Zubik v. Burwell. The Supreme Court held in favor of the Little Sisters of the Poor and ordered HHS to create a religious exemption to the contraceptive mandate.

A true religious and moral exemption to the unconstitutional mandate is long overdue. The Obama Administration failed to respond to the Supreme Court's order, leaving resolution of the case to the Trump Administration. The rules released today are the long-awaited administrative relief groups like the Little Sisters have been seeking since 2010.

As ERLC President, Russell Moore said in response the the rule’s release, “this religious exemption is a crucial achievement in the preservation of religious liberty. The government has no business whatsoever forcing citizens to subsidize the destruction of human life and the exploitation of families and communities.”

The federal government is required by the U.S. Constitution to safeguard religious freedom for all. Trampling the consciences of people of faith—many of whom serve the most vulnerable with love and compassion—hurts society and violates fundamental American principles. Federal regulations should reflect this constitutional constraint on government because as Dr. Moore said, “a government that can pave over the consciences of some can steamroll over dissent everywhere.”

Related Content

What’s in the 2024 Public Policy Agenda?

Public policy advocacy is one of the primary ways that the ERLC fulfills its...

Read More

How a federal agency is attempting to undermine religious liberty in the workplace

When most people hear the phrase “sex-based harassment,” they think of unwanted sexual advances...

Read More

ERLC 2023 State Policy Review

Across the nation state legislative sessions are underway. Though we typically think of Washington,...

Read More

House passes contraception bill that threatens life and religious liberty

The House on Thursday passed the Right to Contraception Act by a final vote...

Read More
religious freedom

Why a truncated vision of religious freedom is dangerous to the common good

One of the most respected evangelical intellectuals of the 20th century, Carl F.H. Henry,...

Read More

USCIRF releases 2022 annual report on international religious freedom

On April 25, the United States Commission on International Religious Freedom (USCIRF) released its...

Read More